Born in the early ‘80s, Nick Hillary is recognized both as a soccer coach and as a participant in a well-publicized legal case. By 2025, Nick Hillary net worth of $1 million dollars, a figure he gained from his legal battles and several post-acquittal settlements, as well as his coaching career. Hillary’s life was upended by the repercussions of a murder allegation which substantially altered the trajectory of both his career and reputation.
Parenting five children, Nick Hillary maintains the status of a dedicated father. Shanna, his eldest, served as an alibi witness during his legal trial and has since expressed her thoughts concerning the impact the murder charge has had on their family. With such hefty burdens to bear, Hillary has worked to improve his life, allowing him to achieve a semblance of financial stability during and after his trial. Nick has become a persistent figure defined by fortitude, tackling his legal challenges in tandem with rebuilding his life. These days, he continues to pursue professional and personal goals while staying out of the public eye.
Quick Bio
| Attribute | Details |
|---|---|
| Full Name | Oral Nick Hillary |
| Date of Birth | June 28, 1974 |
| Place of Birth | Kingston, Jamaica |
| Education | B.S. in Mathematics, St. Lawrence University (2000) |
| Early Life | Moved to U.S. in 1990; attended Samuel Tilden High School in Brooklyn, NY |
| Military Service | U.S. Army enlisted in 1993, served ~2.5 years, honorably discharged with achievement awards |
| Soccer Playing Career | Four-year starter and captain at St. Lawrence University men’s soccer team |
| Notable Achievements | Captain of 1999 undefeated NCAA Division III National Champions team; NSCAA All-American status |
| Coaching Career | Assistant coach at SUNY Potsdam; head coach at Clarkson University (2009–2014) |
| Teaching Career | High school math teacher and head of math department at Admiral Farragut Academy |
| Family | Father of five children; known to keep family life private |
| Residence | Potsdam, New York |
| Public Recognition | Defensive Player of the Year Award named after him at St. Lawrence; inducted into SLU Hall of Fame with 1999 team |
Nick Hillary Net Worth in 2025
As of 2025, Nick Hillary’s estimated net worth nears $1 million. He accumulated this wealth chiefly through his professional activities as a soccer coach, as well as from legal settlements received from his acquittal in a widely publicized murder case. Though his legal struggles adversely impacted his career and public perception, he has succeeded in rebuilding his financial standing.
Also Read More: Kari Lake Net Worth
Business Ventures and Income Sources
Professional Career and Earning Outlets
- Soccer Coaching Career: Mr. Nick Hillary accrued his formative income from his earlier professional soccer coaching roles and having served as a head coach and assistant coach as well as at Clarkson University from 2009 – 2014 and at SUNY Potsdam, respectively.
- Teaching Career: In relation to Mr. Hillary’s teaching career, Admiral Farragut Academy employed him as a high school math teacher and head of the math department.
Legal Settlements and Campaign Support
- Legal Settlements: Nick Hillary’s net worth was legally settled by him receiving money after the notorious legal battle of the criminal trial concerning the murder of Garrett Phillips, a case many assumed Hillary had lost.
- Fundraising Campaigns: Pr as a profession has legally gained them a stream of income for themselves, public relations campaigns for his legal battle helped to the tune of fifty-thousand dollars subsidizing his financial reserve indirectly.
Private and Other Ventures
- The absence of public dealings for Mr. Nick after the legal issues suggest he has, at a minimum, business interests and dealings of a private nature as well as professional pursuits, but detailed publicly available documents outline his current business ventures or investments.
- In relation to how his net worth is acquired, a rough estimate of a million dollars as of the year 2025 is derived from coaching, teaching, legal settlements, and perhaps modest income avenues.
Real State Ownership and Properties
As of the year 2025, there is no publicly available information or confirmation regarding Nick Hillary’s real estate properties or ownership. Relevant profiles and available sources concentrate on Nick Hillary’s career as a soccer coach and teacher, along with his involvement in the widely publicized legal case concerning the murder of Garrett Phillips. There is no indication in media or public records regarding real estate holdings or personal property associated with him. It appears that Nick Hillary has managed to keep his private life, including any possible real estate ventures, under the radar. Any such information, if available, has not been publicly shared.
Personal Life
Family and Children
- Father of Five: Nick Hillary maintains the responsibility of a father to five children.
- Hillary’s eldest daughter, Shanna, participated in his legal proceedings and testified on his behalf which illustrates their bonding.
- Supportive Parent: Shanna characterizes Nick as a caring and robust person which proved to be a great asset in holding the family together during the rigorous legal battles.
- Private About Family: While his legal issues were in the public domain, Hillary chose to shield the majority of information concerning his children and personal affairs from the public eye.
Siblings and Extended Family
- Siblings: Regarding Nick Hillary’s siblings or other relatives, there is no information available. The media, as well as official biographies, concentrate on his and his children’s direct family.
Relationship History
- Relationship with Tandy Cyrus: Nick formerly dated Tandy Cyrus, who is the mother of Garrett Phillips, a victim in the legal saga in which Nick’s name was embroiled.
- Blended Household: At various points, his home comprised of a mix of his children and Tandy Cyrus, which included her children. Garrett and his younger brother, Aaron, portraying a complicated blended family system.
Consequences of Legal Proceedings on Family Dynamics
- Lasting Burden: The social circumstances surrounding the family, including media attention, were aggravated by the social and media requirements of the family heading a trial and the accusations which were levelled against them.
- Cultural and Social Dimensions: Nick’s family life, their societal reputation, and dynamics has irrevocably changed due to considerable social. Cultural, and political events surrounding the trial and its aftermath.
Career Journey
Early Life and Education
- Born on June 28, 1974, in Kingston, Jamaica.
- Moved to the United States in 1990, settling in Brooklyn, New York.
- Attended Samuel Tilden High School in Brooklyn where she was the NYC Player of the Year in 1992 alongside achieving a 3.9 GPA.
- Initially recruited for Division I soccer, she was offered multiple scholarships, but chose to enlist in the U.S. Army first.
Early Coaching Career (2000–2007)
- 2000–2001: Served as assistant men’s soccer coach at SUNY Potsdam for one year.
- 2001-2007: Admiral Farragut Academy in St. Petersburg, Florida as a high school math teacher and head varsity boys’ soccer coach.
- Led the school’s math department as the head of the department, supervising five faculty members and over 350 learners.
Return to College Coaching (2007–2014)
- 2007-2009: Served as assistant men’s soccer coach at St. Lawrence University. Helped the team win a conference championship and qualify for the NCAA tournament.
- 2009-2014: Clarkson University’s Head men’s soccer coach.
- For five seasons, coached Clarkson’s Golden Knights.
- Served as the Student Athlete Advisory Committee representative.
Legal Issues and Exoneration (2014-2016)
- Garrett Phillips’ murder allegation constituted a controversial and media spectacle, leading to widespread public scrutiny that undermined his coaching career.
- His coaching career came to a standstill, and suffering public stigma severely impeded his career progression.
- Phillips was acquitted in 2016, after which he attempted to rebuild his identity and repair the damage to his career.
Post-Trial Developments and The Following Years (2016-2025)
- Phillips sought to address personal and professional challenges and, as a result, did not seek public attention.
- He is estimated to hold a net worth of around one million dollars. Gaining it through coaching, teaching, and legal settlements in the years leading up to 2025.
- He continues to reside in Potsdam, New York.
Struggles with Mental Health, Addiction & Homelessness
Psychological Issues
- The emotional and psychological stressors that Nick Hillary faces are significant after living a scrutinized life and having an entire life shift because he was wrongly accused of murder due to the intense public scrutiny he was placed under.
- In the HBO documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” Hillary expressed that his life after the trial was like “living on house arrest”. He also added that he learned to manipulate his movements in the community which has come at a heavy toll on his mental well-being.
- In his own words, he has come to be socially isolated and disadvantaged because of the scars up his name due to the internet and subsequent background checks which will always be a hindrance to his opportunities and relationships.
Substance Use Disorder or Disorder in Relation to Addiction
- There is no known or publicly detailed verified information as to whether or not Nick Hillary has struggled or is still struggling with substance addiction, no information pointing to addiction being one of his personal hurdles has been brought up.
Challenging Socioeconomic Conditions
- After a lengthy legal battle and subsequent losing his elite status as a soccer coaching professional. He underwent what can be described as profound upheaval in virtually all aspects of his career and life.
- According to reports, the constant bad press surrounding his name. As well as the challenges he faced obtaining reliable background checks, made it almost impossible to find work in his previous field.
- His previous position as a college soccer head coach is now a far cry from his current part-time volunteer coaching position, as reflected in his drastically reduced living standards.
Current Status
Nick Hillary is no longer employed as a college soccer coach as of 2025. Losing his position at Clarkson University in a longitudinal socio-legal fallout of a prominent case he was accused of, and later, exonerated from. Infamously known for his soccer coaching background. Hillary is now engaged in a modest voluntary role coaching youth soccer, along with attempting to piece together his life. To sustain his family, he has had to accept unrelated to coaching jobs such as night shifts, which drastically underutilize his skillset.
According to the publicist for the documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” the prevailing narrative surrounding the case has and continues to loom such that Hillary’s life as a soccer coach has grinded to a halt. Outside of the besmirched narrative. Hillary is devoted to his family which enables him to sustain a semblance of a private life. Out of the public eye, he is active and dedicated to youth soccer at the grassroots level.
Public Perception & Media Coverage
Public Attitude and Coverage Analysis
- In the 2011 Garrett Phillips murder case, Nick Hillary, the ex-boyfriend of Garrett’s mother, was named the primary suspect by the authorities in Potsdam, NY, even prior to the autopsy results indicating homicide.
- Hillary was buzzed about in the media the very day of the murder and by the next day. Suspicion and public outrage was swirling in hefty amounts.
- Hillary was one of the few Black men in the small predominantly white town and suffered racism and xenophobia which further swayed public perception.
In an attempt to Combat Public Perception
- Following the multiple trials, Goldman McCormick Public Relations spearheaded the initiative aimed to counter the stigma and negative media perception surrounding Hillary.
- In 2016, the turning and focal media moments included a five-page feature in the New York Times as well as national broadcast specials from ABC’s 20/20 and NBC’s Dateline.
- Over the course of the campaign, substantial negative media narrative about Hillary was countered and over $50,000 in legal defense funds was raised, which played an important role towards his acquittal.
Post-Acquittal Public and Media Environment
- Following his 2016 acquittal, Hillary still contends with stigma in the community and online because of the scrutiny and media attention of the accusations.
- The Garrett Phillips case is included in the documentary works, such as “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” on HBO. Which emphasized the social, political, and racial dynamics of the case and the subsequent law enforcement response.
- The critics and commentators have largely focused on the Hillary case as an example of a miscarriage of justice in which the police exhibit “tunnel vision” on the suspect based on weak evidence.
FAQs
What is Nick Hillary’s Net Worth in 2024?
Utilizing his previous employment and legal battles in his life, it can be estimated that he is worth roughly 1 million dollars.
What is Nick Hillary Doing Now?
Coaching and public life are not part of his New York state life, where he is focusing on being a father and living under the radar.
How Much Was Nick Hillary’s Settlement Amount?
After losing a civil suit in 2022, he did not receive a prominent settlement.
Who is Tandy Cyrus and Is She Married?
Mother of Garrett Phillips. As of 2024, there is no credible public documentation indicating that she is married.
Who is John Jones in the Garrett Phillips Case?
A deputy sheriff in the area, ex of Tandy Cyrus, and was one of the earlier suspects in the case. But was never charged.
What is the Latest Garrett Phillips Case Update (2024)?
Sporadic publication coverage continues, but the situation itself is static. No further leads are being pursued.
What Was Shown About Nick Hillary on Dateline?
Narrated the story and the surrounding controversy of the trial that ensued after Hillary’s arrest and subsequent acquittal.
Does Nick Hillary Have a Wikipedia Page?
Indeed, but it is crucial to point to the right one: the soccer coach acquitted in the Phillips case and not the Mueller one.
Is Nick Hillary Related to Hillary Banks from The Fresh Prince?
Not at all. ‘Hillary Banks’ is entirely a fabricated persona.
Conclusion
The evolving narrative surrounding Nick Hillary—from a decorated soldier and a championship winning coach to a legally accused individual struggling to redeem his name—reflects a story of tenacity and deep seated controversies. His financial standing in 2024 is estimated to be around one million dollars. Not because of the legal system but owing to his past career earnings. The case of Garrett Phillips remains a case that is still unsolved. It is a divisive case in the context of public reasoning and still captures the imagination. It elicits searches about “Nick Hillary net worth”, “Nick Hillary today”, “Garrett Phillips update 2024” and similar queries.
Also Read More: Roy Firestone Net Worth